The Winners and Losers in Appalachia

It looks like somebody at least is doing his job when it comes to the toxic spill in North Carolina. The United States Attorney’s Office in Raleigh, North Carolina issued grand jury subpoenas to Duke Energy, the company that owns and ran the retired power plant that spilled between 50,000 and 82,000 tons of coal ash into the Dan River, and the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources.

            The subpoenas are asking for emails, memos, and reports related to the spill that occurred nearly two weeks ago. The subpoenas also want information on the state of North Carolina’s oversight of Duke Energy’s 30 other coal ash dumps.

            It turns out that environmental groups had tried to force Duke to clear out leaky coal ash dumps, suing the energy company under terms of the Clean Water Act. In every case, the state of North Carolina blocked the lawsuits. Do you think that the subpoenas have anything to do with this?

            One of the most graphic and sickening pieces of journalism on mountaintop removal is published today over at businessinsider.com. Rightly, they identify this destruction as a product of addiction, our addiction to cheap coal. WARNING: these are graphic and disturbing images. You might think twice before clicking.

            The same website also examines the paradox that is mountaintop removal. Even while billions of tons of coal are being dug out of the mountains of Appalachia, coal jobs have sharply declined in the last couple of years. The article cites the booming of gas production, which is true in this case, as well as environmental regulation, which is false in this regard, as the causes of the downturn.  Quoted in the article is Luke Popovich, a spokesman for the National Mining Association. He says, “There's a gross inconsistency, in our view, of this administration's insistence that it wants to create high-wage jobs and more of them, and the reality that their policies are having on the employment marketplace.”

This is regulated, Mr. Popovich?

The canard of environmental regulation reducing coal jobs is risible. If you had the fortitude to click on the images of mountaintop mining, you can easily see that environmental regulation of this type of mining is nonexistent. As West Virginia Senator Jay Rockefeller recently told NPR, when it comes to coal and West Virginia, he says, “So the industries always win, the people always lose.”